Tuesday, March 04, 2008

The Ethics of Checking Out

Some days, there is a real temptation to head for the hills.

Everyday life can provide ample reason for such feelings. The casual unfairness, cruelty, indifference, and arrogance of others can erode the spirit. The life of a recluse has a siren song that can seem noble in its simplicity.


But is it ethical?


Let's set aside the case of a person who clearly has the potential to find a cure for cancer or some other extraordinary advance. Let us also exempt the individual who needs to get away for a while in order to avoid burn-out.


Can a person who is capable to making life just a bit better for others ethically withdraw that assistance solely in the name of comfort?

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

Not a questions we can answer for others. One must search his own soul for such an answer.

Michael Wade said...

Pawnking,

Kant would ask, "If everyone did it, would it be a good thing?"

In that case, the answer would be no.

Anonymous said...

An ethical justification for slavery? How do you know you are making things better and not worse? A reminder we are paid, not for our efforts, but for our results?

Michael Wade said...

Lord,

I think you may have lost me on the slavery part. I'm not talking about forced servitude. And there are times when you know - to the extent to which knowledge is granted to any of us - that your participation will make things better.